Pit Boss vs. Blackstone Griddle: Comprehensive Griddle Review
It is largely rumoured that Pit Boss is the Blackstone Killer, the brand that will silence the legacy of Blackstone in cooking tantalizing pizzas and steaks. How accurate is this disposition about Pit Boss and Blackstone Griddle? Read till the end to find out more.
There are various griddle brands that you can choose from that will serve as a perfect alternative to standard grills. Griddles combine versatility with creativity to make the most sumptuous meals. Although Pit Boss is mostly known for its pellet grills, they recently released a collection of griddles that easily rivals those of Blackstone.
It almost looks as if Blackstone might win this round of comparison. But don’t be so sure.
A Summary of Pit Boss Griddle
This is a fast-rising brand known for its impeccable products. It is highly durable and versatile, offering different features that make grilling a thrilling experience. Pit Boss offers different pellet barbecues that are well-built.
Despite being relatively new to the market, they’ve set an outstanding record with accurate results, mobility, and power features that offer excellent customer satisfaction. This brand stands out with its ceramic cooking layer that improves your cooking experience.
With this layer, you can make your grills without worrying that they will stick to the surface.
Pit Boss offers you numerous options that vary in size and design. In addition, their griddles come pre-seasoned, saving you the trouble and time required to season your griddle before you can use it. Only pre-seasoning can take up to 30 minutes, and it’s a step you cannot skip because it makes your food taste better. Pit Boss takes out the hassle of burning and oiling your griddle all by yourself.
It also has a decent amount of cooking space that allows you to handle various meals simultaneously. Most of the griddles this company makes can be easily stored by folding them into smaller sizes. You can also clean them through an easy process that only requires you to push them through a hole. The burners are highly durable and sustain a steady temperature throughout their use. However, the heat zones cannot be controlled.
Pit Boss 4 Burner Deluxe Griddle
SPECIFICATIONS
- Dimensions: 76.97 x 24.09 x 35.04 inches
- Material: Stainless Steel
- Weight: 119.7 Pounds
The Pit Boss Griddle is one of the most popular ones for cooking at home, especially for backyard meals. This cooking tool has a space of 753 inches and has a pre-seasoned top with a thickness of 4.7 mm. With this griddle, you never have to bother about pre-seasoning your griddle before making use of it because it comes with all that you need to retain a tasty flavour.
This product stands out with its foldable side shelves that facilitate easy storage and transportation. If you have a small space where you want to store the griddle, you can rest assured that this product will fit perfectly into your space without any hitches. With its handy fold-and-go design, you can easily move your griddle to another place to enjoy sumptuous meals.
Another fascinating feature of this cooking tool is its 62000-BTU burners made of stainless steel. These burners use a simple push-and-turn mechanism that allows you to get them running with ease. You can trust this griddle to serve you for an extensive period with its anti-rusting cast iron griddle that protects it. It is a highly versatile and powerful tool for cooking different meals, such as burgers, biscuits, gravy, cheese steaks, and chilli.
The Pit Boss 4 Burner Deluxe Griddle has 4 controls that allow you to cook different meals simultaneously at different heat levels. Even the side shelves that are foldable can be used as a griddle cover that will allow it to remain safe when you’re not using it. It is also suitable for small-medium gatherings of up to 30 people. This highly functional device allows you to enjoy a mess-free cooking experience.
PROS
- Ample cooking space
- Pre-seasoned top
- Easy storage
- Wheels that facilitate transportation
- Anti-rusting feature
CONS
- The cooking temperature on this griddle is uneven
A Summary of Blackstone Griddles
Since 2005, Blackstone has been in the business of manufacturing griddles. It is popular among home cooks because of its high-end construction that distributes heat evenly. This company uses high-grade rolled steel to produce durable materials known for their long-lasting features. They are also made using powder coating.
It features a massive cooking space that can easily handle full meals. You can also use different temperatures to cook individual meals at the same time. This means you can handle bacon, eggs, chicken, hash browns, and others simultaneously. It also features individual burners that heat equally and can also be controlled independently, which makes your cooking experience eventful.
Many customers across the globe trust Blackstone because of its long history of producing high-quality griddles, which makes it quite popular. Even if you have a small patio, you can remain confident in Blackstone griddles and their capacity to deliver excellent results. It also uses propane as its fuel, making it energy-efficient thus saving you money.
Assembling this griddle is also quite easy, and it takes about an hour to get it completely fixed. Most of the products that this company makes use of a push-button ignition that helps you start the griddle within a split second. This griddle also features some storage space that you can use to keep your utensils and freshly-cooked meals.
Blackstone Flat Top 2 Burner Griddle
SPECIFICATIONS
- Dimensions: 44.5 x 19.5 x 33.5 inches
- Material: Alloy Steel
- Weight: 69 Pounds
If you’re looking to replace your regular grill with something more minimalistic, this Blackstone griddle is a great choice. You require no technical skills to use this griddle; it is easy to use. It saves you the trouble of using wood, kerosene, matches, or charcoal to get the heat running. Blackstone uses the battery-powered push button ignition that helps you start it with ease.
This griddle is a highly versatile device that can be adjusted to up to four different heat zones. With this feature, you can cook various meals on the same surface without burning any of meals. This means some foods can get warm while others can cook completely. It uses a secure footing with 4 wheels that allow you to move the griddle around easily. You can also keep it in one place when you’ve found the right location for it.
In addition, it has an expansive cooktop that has enough room for meals that can feed your party guests. This feature, combined with the 4 adjustable burners, offers the ultimate cooking experience. With this griddle, you can enjoy delicious burgers with a taste that even rivals that of legendary grills.
This griddle is also useful for making meats and stir-fries; it goes beyond these regular meals to accommodate different meats and steak. Despite being a flat-top griddle, it still keeps all the flavours that make your food tasty. In cases where you need that crispy taste, you can trust Blackstone to deliver on that level.
PROS
- Easy assembly
- Four wheels for quick transportation
- Versatile heat zones for different meals
- Energy-efficient griddle
- Prevents messy cooking and makes cleanup easy
CONS
- You cannot fold the sides of this griddle to enjoy better storage.
Which Is Better Pit Boss Or Blackstone Griddles?
Choosing the right one between these two exceptional brands can be pretty overwhelming. You must identify the best product between the two to make a perfect choice. To avoid regrets, you must pay close attention while reading this article.
Cooking Space
The cooking area determines how much food you can cook at once. This is why it is an essential factor that you must consider for the Pit Boss and Blackstone griddle to determine which would be more suitable for the number of people you usually entertain.
According to this review, the Pit Boss 4 burner griddle has a cooking area of 753 inches, which makes it a suitable choice for cooking multiple meals. You can handle whole chicken, bacon, and multiple steaks at the same time.
However, the Blackstone flat top product in this review only has a space of 470 inches, which means it can only contain a few meals. Although the Blackstone 1554 has a cooking area of 720 inches, it still pales compared to the space that Pit Boss offers.
If you’re looking for a griddle with ample space for a larger number of guests, you can settle for the Pit Boss product.
Material
The longevity of your griddle is determined by the type of material used for its construction. The Blackstone griddle uses a steel frame with a powder coating. Even the burners on this cooking tool are made using stainless steel material. Blackstone, as a company, takes durability seriously because it uses a thick cold rolled design for the steel cooktop.
On the other hand, Pit Boss uses stainless steel and cast iron materials to enhance durability. The cast iron material ensures that the cooking tool retains its normal state without rusting.
In terms of materials, you can easily say that Pit Boss and Blackstone are equals even if the latter has been in the business for a longer time.
Burners
The Blackstone griddle in this article uses two burners, although they also have products that use up to four. This brand stands out because it offers users the opportunity to cook at different heat temperatures at the same time. You can trust this griddle to offer an equal cooking experience designed for the specific meal you are handling at that particular time.
Meanwhile, Pit Boss also allows you to cook different meals simultaneously. However, some of the company’s products fail to provide independent controls for each burner to ensure that they heat evenly.
On this note, you can say the Blackstone griddle wins this round.
Storage
Pit Boss griddles help you save space with their foldable side shelves that facilitate easy storage. Also, with their four wheels, you can transport them across different locations to make your cooking experience easier.
Although you can also transport the Blackstone griddle with its wheels, it doesn’t have a foldable feature that makes it compact to save space. However, this Blackstone griddle makes up for its shortcomings by featuring shelves that can be used for storing utensils. It also has a hooded version that the Pit Boss brand doesn’t have.
One can easily say that both products are even on this point.
Usage
You can use both of these products to cook a wide range of meals, ranging from meats, eggs, vegetables, and fish. They are perfect alternatives to grills while still performing at the same level of functionality.
Many customers attest to the capacity of Blackstone for frying food and also sauteing. However, Pit Boss has a higher level of BTUs, making it more suitable for cooking tougher foods. The difference between these two brands is only minimal in this aspect.
Cleaning
Hygiene is a major aspect of cooking, and you need a griddle that will make the cleaning process hassle-free. Luckily, both brands gave the utmost consideration when building their griddles to ensure they were mess-free. You can also use spatulas to remove the grease and the pieces of food lingering on the surface. Once you’re done, you can direct everything into the grease catchers to ensure that it is clean when you use it next. Using water and soap to clean the griddles is quite okay; however, you have to pre-season them before cooking.
Final Verdict: Which Is Better?
Pit Boss released products that can give Blackstone a run for their money. However, that doesn’t mean that Blackstone griddles are dead either, just that there are emerging competitors that are performing well. Both have reliable performance that you can trust for cooking whole meals.
Pit Boss offers relatively affordable products compared to Blackstone. If you’re looking for something that still gives high performance but is within your budget, you can choose Pit Boss.
However, Blackstone hasn’t remained on top merely because of its name and has lived up to its hype. If we were meant to choose between these two products, we would choose the Blackstone product because of its high-performance level, despite being more expensive than Pit Boss.
