A flat top griddle is the most versatile surface in a backyard, and it is also one of the easiest pieces of cooking equipment to buy wrong. The mistake is rarely the brand. It is buying a surface that does not match how you actually cook: a 22 inch unit for a family of six, a countertop model for someone who wants to feed a block party, or a griddle with no hood when every cook ends with a melt or a lid. This guide compares six flat top griddle options currently offered, from a hooded 22 inch griddle to a 28 inch bundle and a carbon steel set that works indoors, and it explains which one fits which job. Nothing here is a ranking of brands. It is a comparison of formats, sizes, and what arrives in the box.
Related: How to Season a Flat Top Griddle So It Lasts
Quick answer
The ® 2450AZ 28" Omnivore Griddle with Hood Bundle is the strongest fit for backyard cooks who want one of the larger surfaces in this group with a hood included, because the 28 inch footprint covers more food per batch and the hood covers the surface between sessions. Choose the ONLYFIRE GRILLS Heavy Duty Propane Gas Griddle 2-Burner with Cart, GS351 instead when you want a two burner propane griddle that stands on its own cart rather than sitting on a table.
Flat top griddles worth comparing
The six products below fall into three groups. Three are complete propane griddles with their own frame or cart. One is a drop in surface for a gas grill or stove you already own. One is a carbon steel griddle set for an induction range or a grill. The last is a cleaning tool that keeps any of them usable. Compare the format first, then the size, then the extras.
® 2450AZ 28" Omnivore Griddle with Hood Bundle
A 28 inch Omnivore griddle that arrives with a hood as part of a bundle. The wider surface suits longer cooks, and the hood covers the top between sessions.
Visit on Amazon
® 2350 OTG 22" Omnivore Griddle with Hood, Black
A 22 inch Omnivore griddle with a hood, finished in black. The smaller footprint fits patios and balconies where a 28 inch unit will not.
Visit on Amazon
ONLYFIRE GRILLS Heavy Duty Propane Gas Griddle 2-Burner with Cart, GS351
A heavy duty propane gas griddle with two burners and a cart. The cart format means the griddle stands on its own instead of resting on a table.
Visit on Amazon
Hisencn 25"x16" Flat Top Griddle for Gas Grill and Stove, 4-5 Burner Grills
Check current Amazon price
A 25 by 16 inch flat top griddle made to sit on a gas grill or stove with four to five burners, converting an existing grill into a griddle surface.
Visit on Amazon
Made In Cookware - Carbon Steel Griddle and Grill Press Set with Half Lid - Professional Cookware - Crafted in Sweden - Induction Compatible
A carbon steel griddle and grill press set with a half lid, crafted in Sweden and induction compatible, so it works on an indoor range as well as over a grill.
Visit on Amazon
4 Pack Grill Cleaner Brick for Outdoor&Restaurant. Heavy Duty Grill Cleaning Brick. Pumice Stone Cleaner Tool Grill Brick for Cleaning Flat Top Grills Griddles Effectively Without Harsh Chemicals
A four pack of pumice cleaning bricks for flat top grills and griddles, positioned as a way to lift burnt on residue without harsh chemicals.
Visit on AmazonPrices and availability may change. Check the retailer for current details.
How these products were compared
This guide compares cooking surface dimensions and footprint, burner count and zone layout, whether a hood or lid is included, the format of the unit, and what arrives in the box versus what you buy separately. Cleaning and maintenance needs are part of the comparison too, because a griddle you cannot keep clean is a griddle you stop using.
Product names, images, and retailer links are matched by product identifier so that every card points to the product shown. The details here come from the manufacturer product listings rather than from a hands on test, so treat each summary as a starting point and confirm the exact specifications on the listing before you buy. No current price is printed in this article; use the retailer link on any card to check price and availability.
How to choose the right flat top griddle
Start with the space, not the surface. Measure the patio, deck, or counter where the griddle will live, then subtract the clearance you need to stand in front of it and to open a hood. A 28 inch griddle is not twice the griddle a 22 inch model is; it is a different commitment to floor space, cover, and storage.
Then decide the format. A cart mounted propane griddle is a standalone appliance. A drop in flat top is an accessory that turns an existing four or five burner gas grill into a griddle for the price of a surface, which is often the least expensive route if you already own the grill. A carbon steel griddle is the flexible option: induction compatible, so it works on an indoor range as well as over a fire, and small enough to store in a cabinet.
Burner count matters less than burner layout, because independent zones are what let you hold one area low for eggs while another runs hot for searing. A hood is worth paying for if you finish foods with cheese, steam vegetables, or leave the griddle outside between cooks. Look hard at the grease management and the cleaning routine before you buy; if the trap is awkward to remove or the surface is hard to scrape, you will feel it every single cook. If you are new to steel surfaces, read our griddle cleaning and seasoning routine before you decide what to buy.
® 2450AZ 28" Omnivore Griddle with Hood Bundle
The 28 inch Omnivore griddle with hood is the largest complete griddle in this group, and it arrives as a bundle, which means the hood and the package contents come together rather than as separate purchases. For anyone cooking for a crowd, the extra width over a 22 inch unit is the difference between two batches of smash burgers and three, and the hood gives you a place to melt cheese or hold finished food.
The trade off is footprint and commitment. A 28 inch griddle needs more patio space, a larger cover, and more room in the garage over winter than a smaller unit. Bundles can also include items you already own, so read the package contents carefully and compare what is actually in the box against what you would buy anyway.
Alternatives to consider
The ® 2350 OTG 22" Omnivore Griddle with Hood, Black is better suited to smaller patios, balconies, and couples or small families, where a 22 inch surface is enough for a normal weeknight and the hood still gives you a covered cook. The ONLYFIRE GRILLS Heavy Duty Propane Gas Griddle 2-Burner with Cart, GS351 is a stronger fit when you want a standalone cart mounted propane griddle with two burners and do not want to buy or build a separate stand.
The Hisencn 25"x16" Flat Top Griddle for Gas Grill and Stove, 4-5 Burner Grills, the Made In Cookware - Carbon Steel Griddle and Grill Press Set with Half Lid - Professional Cookware - Crafted in Sweden - Induction Compatible, and the 4 Pack Grill Cleaner Brick for Outdoor&Restaurant. Heavy Duty Grill Cleaning Brick. Pumice Stone Cleaner Tool Grill Brick for Cleaning Flat Top Grills Griddles Effectively Without Harsh Chemicals cover the other three jobs. The Hisencn surface converts a four or five burner gas grill into a flat top, the Made In set brings an induction compatible carbon steel griddle and press indoors or over a fire, and the cleaning bricks handle the burnt on residue that every flat top collects.
Day-to-day use and maintenance
Every steel surface in this guide behaves the same way: it gets better with use and worse with neglect. Seasoning is a habit rather than a one time event. Thin coats of oil, heat until the surface darkens, repeat. Scrape the griddle while it is still hot, push the residue into the grease trap, and wipe the surface with a thin film of oil before you walk away.
None of these products is rust proof, and no listing should convince you otherwise. Carbon steel and cold rolled steel rust when moisture sits on them, so dry the surface after cleaning and oil it before storage. If you live somewhere humid, check the surface between cooks rather than assuming it is fine.
The cleaning bricks are for the heavy jobs: polymerized buildup, burnt sugar, and the black crust that forms after a long breakfast service. They work on flat top griddles and restaurant style grills without harsh chemicals, which matters if you cook for people with sensitivities or you dislike the smell of oven cleaner. Pair them with a scraper and a squeeze bottle of oil, and you have the whole kit.
A few practical cautions. Let any griddle cool before you move it, because a full grease trap and a hot surface are a bad combination. Check that the grease cup or channel on your model is removable and easy to reach, since that is the part that decides whether cleanup takes two minutes or twenty. And if you cook on a cart mounted unit, confirm the cart is level and the wheels lock, because a griddle that rolls mid cook is a hazard, not a feature.
Buying checklist
- Measure the patio, deck, or counter space, including clearance for the cook and for opening a hood.
- Choose the cooking surface size based on a normal weeknight, not the one party you host each summer.
- Decide the format first: cart mounted, drop in for an existing grill, or a countertop carbon steel griddle.
- Confirm that the exact model includes the hood, lid, or bundle contents you are counting on.
- Read the cleaning and maintenance instructions, especially for the grease management system.
- Verify the current retailer price, availability, and return terms before you order.
Final recommendation
Choose the ® 2450AZ 28" Omnivore Griddle with Hood Bundle when you have the space and you want one of the larger hooded surfaces in this group for cooking in batches. Choose the ONLYFIRE GRILLS Heavy Duty Propane Gas Griddle 2-Burner with Cart, GS351 when you want a standalone two burner propane griddle on its own cart. Choose the ® 2350 OTG 22" Omnivore Griddle with Hood, Black when space is tight, the Hisencn 25"x16" Flat Top Griddle for Gas Grill and Stove, 4-5 Burner Grills when you already own a four or five burner grill and want to convert it, and the Made In Cookware - Carbon Steel Griddle and Grill Press Set with Half Lid - Professional Cookware - Crafted in Sweden - Induction Compatible when you want a griddle that works on an induction range indoors. Add the 4 Pack Grill Cleaner Brick for Outdoor&Restaurant. Heavy Duty Grill Cleaning Brick. Pumice Stone Cleaner Tool Grill Brick for Cleaning Flat Top Grills Griddles Effectively Without Harsh Chemicals to whichever one you pick, because the cleaning tool is what keeps the surface worth cooking on.