A flat top griddle setup is not one product. It is a decision about where you cook, what you cook most often, and what you already own. You want one hot surface that handles eggs, smash burgers, pancakes, fried rice, and a pile of onions without juggling six pans. The trouble is that the label covers four very different pieces of equipment: a propane grill and griddle in one cabinet with a lid, a countertop electric pan that runs off a wall outlet, a slab of cast iron you drop onto a grill you already have, and a hand tool that makes smash burgers and searing weights practical. Buy the wrong one and you end up with a surface too small for a family cook, or a machine that duplicates gear already sitting in the garage.
Related: How to Season a Flat Top Griddle So It Stays Nonstick →
Quick answer
The right flat top griddle setup follows your heat source, not the size of the cooking surface. The Royal Gourmet PD1305H is a 3-burner propane gas grill and griddle combo with a lid, which suits outdoor gas cooking on a deck or patio. The Gourmia 22 Inch XL Electric Griddle Pan is a countertop unit with an extra large ceramic nonstick surface, adjustable temperature from 200°F to 400°F, and a pull-out drip tray, which suits indoor or covered cooking where propane is not an option. The Camp Chef Cast Iron Griddle is a 16 by 24 inch cast iron surface with griddle and grill sides, which suits anyone adding a flat top to a grill or camp stove they already own. The Pisol Smash Burger Press is a cast iron tool for pressing patties, forming meat, and weighing down food. None of these replaces the others, and none is automatically the right purchase for your kitchen.
Four useful options
| Model | Best fit | What stands out |
|---|---|---|
| Royal Gourmet PD1305H 3-Burner Propane Gas Grill, Griddle Combo with Lid | Outdoor gas cooking on a deck or patio | Propane grill and griddle in one unit, with a lid |
| Gourmia 22 Inch XL Electric Griddle Pan | Countertop and indoor cooking | 22 inch ceramic nonstick surface, adjustable 200°F to 400°F, pull-out drip tray |
| Camp Chef Cast Iron Griddle - 16 x 24 | Adding a flat top to gear you already own | 16 by 24 inch cast iron with griddle and grill sides |
| Pisol Smash Burger Press | Smash burgers, patty forming, pressing | Cast iron press and steak weight in one tool |
The outdoor gas option: Royal Gourmet PD1305H 3-Burner Propane Gas Grill, Griddle Combo with Lid
A combo unit solves a footprint problem. Instead of a grill parked on one side of the patio and a griddle on the other, one cabinet holds both, and the lid lets you shut the surface down when the wind picks up or when you want heat to build around what you are cooking. The trade-off is that combos ask you to share one body between two cooking styles, so the griddle area is whatever the layout leaves for it, and you are committed to propane. If your cooking happens on a deck, a driveway, or a tailgate, that trade is usually worth it. If you live somewhere propane is banned on balconies, it is not.
The countertop electric option: Gourmia 22 Inch XL Electric Griddle Pan
This is the option for anyone whose cooking happens indoors or on a covered patio where open flame is not practical. Electric heat comes from elements under the plate rather than from a flame licking the underside of steel, so the surface responds differently: it tends to heat more evenly across the whole area but recovers differently when you load it with cold food. The pull-out drip tray matters more than most buyers expect, because grease that has nowhere to go pools at the edge of the plate and burns. The handle-free shape is a storage decision as much as a design one, since it slides into a cabinet without a protruding grip getting in the way.
The cast iron drop-in option: Camp Chef Cast Iron Griddle - 16 x 24, Non-Stick Grill/Griddle Sides
Read the description carefully here, because this is not a machine. It is a slab. It goes on a grill, a camp stove, or a fire ring you already have, which makes it the cheapest way into flat top cooking for someone who already owns a heat source. Cast iron behaves differently from the rolled steel used on most gas griddles: it takes longer to come up to temperature, then holds that heat when a cold patty hits the surface. It is also heavy, and heavy means you handle it with two hands and dry it thoroughly before it goes away. Cast iron left damp is cast iron that rusts.
The tool option: Pisol Smash Burger Press, Cast Iron Steak Weight Meat Patty Press Tool
A smash burger is a technique, not a recipe, and the technique needs weight. Hot surface, thin layer of oil, ball of beef, press it flat, hold for a few seconds, and leave it alone until the crust sets. Press it twice and you squeeze out the juice you were trying to keep. A cast iron press gives you flat contact and enough mass to push the patty down evenly instead of denting one side. The same tool works as a steak weight when you want full surface contact on a thick cut, and it forms patties when you want consistent rounds. It is the cheapest item in this group and the one most likely to change how often you cook on whatever surface you end up buying.
Prices and availability may change. Product images, names, and retailer links are matched to verified listings. No current price, rating, stock status, or measured result is stated here without current evidence.
Burner zones and surface material: what actually changes your cooking
Burner count matters far less than burner layout. A griddle with independent zones lets you run one area screaming hot for searing while another sits low for holding pancakes or keeping a pile of onions warm. That is the difference between cooking a full breakfast and cooking one thing at a time. When you look at any gas griddle, ask how the heat is divided across the surface. Two well-separated zones are more useful than four burners crowded into the middle of a narrow plate.
Material drives how the surface behaves under load. Rolled steel is lighter and responds quickly to burner adjustments, which is why most gas griddles use it. Cast iron is heavier, heats slowly, and holds heat through a cold load, which is why it excels at searing and why it feels sluggish when you want to drop the temperature fast. Electric plates heat from embedded elements, so the whole surface tends to come up together and the control dial changes output rather than flame size.
Thin steel is the recurring weak point on inexpensive griddles. A plate that is too thin develops hot spots over the burners and cool spots between them, and it can warp if it is heated hard and cooled fast. You do not need commercial thickness at home, but you do want a surface that stays flat, because a warped griddle means oil pools on one side and burgers cook unevenly forever.
Seasoning and grease management: the two habits that decide everything
Seasoning is a habit, not a purchase. It is a thin layer of polymerized oil built up over many cooks: wipe a small amount of oil across a clean, warm surface, let it heat until it stops looking wet, and repeat. Do that after most cooks and the surface darkens and releases food. Skip it for a month and you will meet rust, no matter what the marketing copy says about any coating. A griddle that rusts was neglected, not defective.
Grease management decides whether you cook or fight. On a gas griddle, fat runs toward a trap or a channel, and if that trap is awkward to remove and clean, fat sits there and turns into a science experiment. A removable cup you can dump and wash in the sink is worth more than an extra inch of cooking surface. On an electric countertop unit, the pull-out drip tray does the same job, and it needs emptying before it overflows, not after.
The scraper is the other half of the system. A flat metal scraper used while the surface is still hot lifts the stuck bits and pushes the residue toward the trap. Scrape, wipe with a rag, oil lightly, and the surface is ready for the next cook. That three-step routine takes less time than washing a pan.
Five steps to narrow it down
- Count what you actually cook in a normal week. If it is eggs, pancakes, and burgers, a wide flat surface earns its space. If it is mostly one protein, a smaller surface is enough.
- Identify your heat source first. Propane outdoors, a wall outlet indoors, or a grill you already own. The heat source eliminates half the options immediately.
- Measure the space you will store it in, not just the space you will cook in. Countertop units and drop-in surfaces have very different storage demands.
- Check how grease leaves the surface and whether you can clean that path in under a minute.
- Decide whether you are buying a cooker or a surface. A surface only makes sense if something in your garage can heat it.
What to check before you buy
- Whether the surface is flat and stays flat under heat, since warping is a permanent problem
- How many independent heat zones exist and how they are spaced across the plate
- Whether the grease trap or drip tray comes out easily for washing
- Whether the material is cast iron, rolled steel, or a coated electric plate, because each one demands different care
- Whether you need a lid for wind protection, warming, and covering the surface between cooks
Which option should you choose?
Choose the Royal Gourmet PD1305H 3-Burner Propane Gas Grill, Griddle Combo with Lid when you cook outdoors on a deck, patio, or driveway and want gas heat with a lid over the surface. Choose the Gourmia 22 Inch XL Electric Griddle Pan when your cooking happens indoors or on a covered balcony and you want a large flat surface that runs off a standard outlet. Choose the Camp Chef Cast Iron Griddle - 16 x 24 when you already own a grill or camp stove and want to add a cast iron flat top without buying another machine. Choose the Pisol Smash Burger Press when smash burgers, searing weights, and consistent patties are part of how you cook.
A caveat worth stating plainly: how any of these performs depends on how you run it. Heat distribution, seasoning, and grease handling are things you influence with preheating, oiling, and cleaning, not fixed properties you simply receive. The listings describe construction and features. They do not describe the cook standing in front of them.
The bottom line
Match the surface to the heat source and the space you actually have, then treat seasoning and grease management as routine maintenance rather than optional extras. The propane combo covers outdoor gas cooking with a lid. The electric countertop unit covers indoor cooking with adjustable temperature and a pull-out drip tray. The cast iron griddle covers anyone adding a flat top to equipment they already own. The cast iron press covers the technique that makes a flat top worth owning in the first place. Buy the one that fits the way you cook on a Tuesday night, not the one that fits a photo of a weekend party.